(In Australia) Erin Patterson Found Guilty of Mushroom Poisoning Murders

 

On July 29, 2023, Erin Patterson hosted a lunch at her home in Leongatha, Australia. Her guests included her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson and family friends Heather and Ian Wilkinson. By the end of the week, Gail, Don, and Heather were dead. Ian survived but only after spending weeks in a coma.

Erin, who prepared the meal, claimed it was an unfortunate accident involving store-bought and foraged mushrooms. But details quickly raised suspicions. Erin served herself on a different colored plate and didn’t fall seriously ill. Investigators later discovered she had lied about a cancer diagnosis to gain sympathy and potentially lure her guests.

She claimed to suffer from bulimia to explain vomiting after the meal, suggesting this prevented her from getting sick. The court also learned she disposed of a food dehydrator linked to the poisoning and wiped data from her phone while under investigation.

Further digital evidence showed she had visited websites with information on deadly mushrooms and purchased a dehydrator on the same route she traveled through towns where death caps had recently been seen.

Despite her insistence she loved her in-laws and had no reason to harm them, the inconsistencies kept mounting. A suspicious cake, changing stories, and missing phones all added to the mystery.

Erin’s trial lasted nine weeks, drawing national and global attention. Throughout the proceedings, she remained calm and emotionless. Her defense argued there was no clear motive. They said Erin was a misunderstood woman panicking over an accidental tragedy.

But the prosecution painted a different picture. They described Erin as someone who had woven a complex web of lies  from a made-up cancer diagnosis to false claims about where she sourced the mushrooms. They alleged she disposed of key evidence, like a food dehydrator, and used three phones, two of which vanished shortly after the lunch.

Digital forensics showed Erin browsing posts about deadly mushrooms and even posting on Facebook about secretly using mushrooms in food for her children. Photos recovered showed suspicious mushrooms being weighed in her kitchen.

The prosecution didn’t present a specific motive, but they suggested Erin had growing frustration with her former in-laws and was feeling isolated. The lack of motive didn’t sway the jury, who were asked to focus on the overwhelming circumstantial evidence and pattern of lies.

Despite attempts by her lawyers to explain each red flag, the jury was not convinced. They found her guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder. Erin Patterson now faces life in prison, with her sentencing to be decided soon.

The case has shocked the country, both for the gruesome nature of the deaths and the chilling calm of the woman at the center of it all. What started as a family lunch ended with three coffins, a courtroom drama, and a legacy of unanswered questions.

See also: Trump calls Musk's formation of new party "ridiculous" and criticizes his own NASA pick