15 talents who wasted their potential in the NFL

 The NFL is a league of elite athletes, where only a tiny fraction of players make the cut. Despite their hard work and dedication, some talented players fail to live up to expectations due to various reasons such as off-field issues, injuries, or poor decisions.

see also: A look at the best Real Madrid comebacks

 Here are 15 NFL players who showed flashes of brilliance but ultimately fell short of their potential.

Ryan Leaf - Drafted second overall in 1998 by the San Diego Chargers, Leaf was touted as a generational quarterback prospect alongside Peyton Manning. His strong arm and college success at Washington State set high expectations, but his NFL career was derailed by poor work ethic, immaturity, and conflicts with teammates and media. He threw just 14 touchdowns against 36 interceptions in 25 games, becoming one of the biggest draft busts in NFL history.

JaMarcus Russell - The first overall pick in 2007 by the Oakland Raiders, Russell had elite physical tools, including a cannon arm and imposing size. His college performance at LSU suggested stardom, but he struggled with weight issues, work ethic, and preparation, reportedly skipping meetings and failing to grasp playbooks. In three seasons, he went 7-18 as a starter with 18 touchdowns and 23 interceptions, flaming out quickly.

Josh Gordon - A supremely gifted wide receiver, Gordon led the NFL in receiving yards (1,646) in 2013 with the Cleveland Browns despite playing only 14 games. His athleticism and playmaking ability were unmatched, but repeated suspensions for substance abuse violations derailed his career. He bounced between teams, never recapturing his early dominance, and remains a “what-if” story.

Justin Blackmon - Selected fifth overall in 2012 by the Jacksonville Jaguars, Blackmon showed immediate promise as a dynamic wide receiver, with 865 yards in his rookie season. His size, speed, and hands suggested a bright future, but substance abuse issues led to multiple suspensions. He last played in 2013, unable to overcome personal struggles despite his undeniable talent.

see also: Six goals and five assists for Real Madrid in 2025: What the hell has happened to Vinicius Jr?!

Aldon Smith - A dominant pass rusher, Smith recorded 33.5 sacks in his first two seasons (2011-12) with the San Francisco 49ers, earning All-Pro honors. His combination of speed and power made him a Defensive Player of the Year candidate, but off-field issues, including DUIs and substance abuse, led to suspensions and team releases. He never sustained his early success.

Johnny Manziel - The 2012 Heisman Trophy winner and 2014 first-round pick by the Cleveland Browns, Manziel’s electrifying college play at Texas A&M didn’t translate to the NFL. His improvisational style and charisma were overshadowed by off-field partying, substance abuse, and a lack of preparation. He started just eight games, posting a 2-6 record before exiting the league.

Lawrence Phillips - A sixth overall pick in 1996 by the St. Louis Rams, Phillips was a powerful running back with elite speed and vision, showcased during his time at Nebraska. However, legal troubles, including domestic violence and other arrests, plagued his career. He played only 35 NFL games, and his life ended tragically in prison, where he died in 2016.

Randy Gregory - A second-round pick in 2015 by the Dallas Cowboys, Gregory’s explosive pass-rushing ability out of Nebraska hinted at stardom. However, multiple suspensions for violating the NFL’s substance abuse policy limited him to just 12 games in his first four seasons. While he later showed flashes of potential, he never became the consistent force expected.

Martavis Bryant - Drafted in the fourth round in 2014 by the Pittsburgh Steelers, Bryant’s rare combination of size (6’4”) and speed made him a deep-threat receiver, with 1,314 yards and 14 touchdowns in his first two seasons. Substance abuse suspensions and inconsistent play led to trades and releases, preventing him from becoming a top-tier receiver.

Dion Jordan - The third overall pick in 2013 by the Miami Dolphins, Jordan was an athletic freak as a defensive end from Oregon. His versatility and speed suggested a high ceiling, but suspensions for performance-enhancing drugs and a lack of production (only 3 sacks in 26 games with Miami) stunted his career. He bounced around the league with minimal impact.

Aaron Hernandez - A fourth-round pick in 2010 by the New England Patriots, Hernandez was a matchup nightmare as a tight end, with 1,956 yards and 18 touchdowns in three seasons. His athleticism and route-running were elite, but his career was cut short by legal issues, including a murder conviction in 2015, which led to his imprisonment and eventual death in 2017.

see also: Every Champions League finalists losing manager since the inception in 1992

Todd Marinovich - A first-round pick in 1991 by the Los Angeles Raiders, Marinovich was a highly touted quarterback from USC with a strong arm and football IQ. However, his career was derailed by drug addiction, which began in college and worsened in the NFL. He played just eight games, throwing 8 touchdowns and 9 interceptions, before leaving the league.

Vince Young - The third overall pick in 2006 by the Tennessee Titans, Young was a dual-threat quarterback who led Texas to a national championship. He earned Offensive Rookie of the Year honors and a Pro Bowl nod in 2006, but inconsistent play, mental health struggles, and conflicts with coaches limited him to 31 career starts despite his immense physical gifts.

Maurice Clarett - A third-round pick in 2005 by the Denver Broncos, Clarett was a star at Ohio State, rushing for 1,237 yards as a freshman. Legal issues and a tumultuous pre-draft process dropped his stock, and off-field troubles, including an arrest before his first season, led to his release without playing an NFL game. His career never recovered.

Greg Hardy - A sixth-round pick in 2010 by the Carolina Panthers, Hardy developed into a premier pass rusher, recording 26 sacks from 2012-13. His athleticism and intensity were unmatched, but a 2014 domestic violence incident led to a suspension and damaged his reputation. He played only one more season with Dallas, never regaining his prior form.