Exola Predictions Feb 14, 2025.

Ruben Amorim's Challenge: Can He Bring Stability to Manchester United?



 In the football world, few clubs have seen as much managerial turnover in the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era as Manchester United. The recent sacking of Erik ten Hag has reignited debates across the UK, with fans and pundits alike dissecting the club's ongoing struggles. The term "sack" has trended heavily in the United Kingdom, not just for the immediate news of Ten Hag's dismissal but for the broader conversation about what has gone wrong at Old Trafford.



read also: Ex-Man Utd first-team coach Benni McCarthy to become national team boss in first job since leaving Old Trafford

Since Ferguson retired in 2013, Manchester United has cycled through a series of high-profile managers, each bringing their own philosophy and tactics to the club. David Moyes was the first to take the mantle but lasted less than a season, criticized for his inability to maintain the club's competitive edge. His tenure highlighted the immense pressure and perhaps unrealistic expectations placed on his shoulders, especially following the legendary success of his predecessor.




Next came Louis van Gaal, who managed to secure an FA Cup but was let go despite this achievement. His tactical approach, often described as too cautious, didn't align with the fans' desire for the attacking, free-flowing football they associated with United's glory days. His exit was a reminder that trophies alone aren't enough when the style of play doesn't resonate with the club's identity.


Jose Mourinho, a serial winner, seemed like the perfect fit on paper. However, his tenure ended in discord, with his relationship with players and the media souring. His pragmatic, results-driven approach initially brought success, including an Europa League triumph, but the subsequent seasons saw a decline in performance, leading to his dismissal amid accusations of creating a negative atmosphere.




Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, a club legend, was supposed to bring back the magic. His initial impact was electric, but over time, his tactical naivety became apparent under the scrutiny of top-level football. His exit was emotional but inevitable, reflecting a broader issue at United - a lack of strategic vision beyond immediate results.


The latest in this series, Erik ten Hag, came with accolades from Ajax, promising a return to possession-based football. His time at United was marked by a League Cup win and an FA Cup victory, but these successes were overshadowed by inconsistent league performances and a lack of progress in the Champions League. His sacking in 2024, after a dismal start to the season, has left fans questioning not just the manager but the system behind him.


The crux of the debate among Manchester United's fanbase isn't just about the individuals who've sat in the manager's seat but about systemic failures at the club. There's a growing consensus that the problem transcends individual managers. Fans argue that it's about the lack of a clear footballing philosophy, poor recruitment strategies, and the ownership's involvement in footballing decisions. 


With Ruben Amorim now taking the helm, there's cautious optimism. His track record at Sporting Lisbon, where he won a league title with a blend of attacking flair and tactical discipline, suggests he could be the right fit. However, the narrative among fans is clear: success for Amorim will require not just his managerial acumen but also systemic changes at the club.


Part of this systemic overhaul, fans suggest, should include specialized roles like set-piece coaches. Manchester United's struggles from dead balls have been a glaring issue, and addressing these finer tactical points could make a significant difference in match outcomes. 



read also: Kenya's Cry for Change: #OccupyStateHouse Movement Gains Momentum


The ongoing discussions among Manchester United supporters underscore a desire for more than just managerial change; they're calling for a renaissance in how the club is run from top to bottom. The fans want a return to the ethos of youth development, smart recruitment, and a playing style that echoes the club's storied past. 


In conclusion, the saga of Manchester United's managerial changes post-Ferguson is not just a story of sackings but a narrative of a club in search of its identity. The next few years under Amorim's guidance will be pivotal, not just for the new manager but for the entire structure of Manchester United. The hope is for a new era where the focus isn't on who to sack next but how to sustainably build success.

Comments