Why Lamine Yamal should not win the 2025 Ballon d’Or

 

Yes, he’s a generational talent. But many fans, pundits, and ex-players argue it’s too soon. 

Here’s why

Stats don’t stack up

Yamal scored 21 goals in all comps (9 in La Liga). Decent for a 17-year-old, but nowhere near elite Ballon d’Or levels.

Compare: Ousmane Dembélé – 37 goals + 14 assists, driving PSG to a treble.

See also: Ronaldinho to present 2025 Ballon d’Or as Dembele and Yamal battle for top prize

Not enough trophies

Barcelona crashed out in the UCL semis. Spain lost the Nations League final.

Meanwhile, Dembele lifted 4 trophies with PSG including the Champions League. Voters usually reward winners.

Off-field controversies

Reports of excessive partying, controversial relationships, and missed training have raised maturity concerns.

Critics argue the Ballon d’Or should honour professionalism as well as talent.

See also: This former Man Utd XI is currently thriving away from Old Trafford

Too young, too soon

At 18, Yamal has time on his side. Even Hansi Flick says he’ll win “one day” - but not yet.

Awarding him now risks looking like hype over substance.

Bottom line

Lamine Yamal is a superstar in the making, but 2025 should belong to someone with stronger stats, trophies, and consistency.

For many, that’s Ousmane Dembélé.

See also: (In the US) 49years Star Nick Bosa Exits Game with Concerning Injury