The Wonderkids Who Didn’t Make It

The Wonderkids Who Didn’t Make It 

Not every teenage prodigy becomes a superstar.

Here are 9 Premier League wonderkids who broke through early… but never fulfilled the hype 

Andy Turner (Tottenham, 1992)

Debut at 17.

Became the PL’s youngest scorer.

Fell out of favour, serious ankle injury → journeyman career in lower leagues.

See also: Athletic’s Yeray Álvarez Handed 10-Month UEFA Ban for Accidental Doping

James Vaughan (Everton, 2005)

Scored on debut at 16 (still the youngest PL scorer ever).

Plagued by injuries, managed just 7 PL goals.

Found success later in the lower leagues.

Michael Johnson (Man City, 2006)

Box-to-box midfielder tipped for England stardom.

Long-term injuries + mental health struggles ended career at 24.

Left football completely.

Matthew Briggs (Fulham, 2007)

Debut at 16, fifth-youngest PL player ever.

Couldn’t handle the pressure.

Only 13 PL games before journeyman career + Guyana caps.

See also: ‘Magnifico’: Fans Celebrate Bruno Fernandes on 31st Birthday

Jose Baxter (Everton, 2008)

Debuted at 16, once hailed as “the next Rooney.”

Just 5 PL appearances.

Battles with drugs & depression, later rebuilt career in lower leagues

Federico Macheda (Man United, 2009)

 Iconic debut goal vs Aston Villa at 17, sparked a title race.

Scored only 3 more PL goals.

Career in Championship, Greece & Turkey.

See also: Repeat Offender Luis Suarez Handed Lengthy Ban After Spitting Shame

Izzy Brown (West Brom/Chelsea, 2013)

Debuted at 16, moved to Chelsea.

Only 16 PL apps across loans.

Retired at 26 due to Achilles injury.

Reece Oxford (West Ham, 2015)

Starred at 16 vs Arsenal, hailed as the next Rio Ferdinand.

Only 8 PL games.

Carved out career in Germany, but released by Augsburg in 2024.

See also: PSG boss Luis Enrique faces surgery after nasty cycling injury

Honourable Mention: Michael Owen (Liverpool, 1997)

Another teenage breakout… except he did make it.

Ballon d’Or winner.

But even he was broken by injuries by 29.