Leave Man United and succeed — Fans warn players after McTominay wins Serie A MVP award

 

Scott McTominay’s remarkable debut season at Napoli has ignited discussions among football fans, particularly Manchester United supporters, following his Serie A MVP award and title win in 2024-25. The Scottish midfielder, who spent 22 years at United, joined Napoli for £25.7 million and delivered 12 goals and four assists, including a decisive overhead kick in Napoli’s 2-0 victory over Cagliari that secured the championship. 

His success has fueled a narrative on platforms like X that leaving Manchester United unlocks player potential. Fans point to other former United players excelling elsewhere: Antony, now at Real Betis, has eight goals and five assists; Mason Greenwood is impressing at Marseille; and Dean Henderson won the FA Cup with Crystal Palace. These cases contrast sharply with United’s struggles, as the club languished in the Premier League’s bottom half and lost the Europa League final under new manager Ruben Amorim.

 Social media posts reflect fan frustration, with sentiments like “Leave United and win something” gaining traction, alongside criticism of United’s decision to sell McTominay to fund other signings. Some fans argue the club’s current environment stifles talent, citing McTominay’s transformation from a squad player to a star under Napoli’s Antonio Conte. 

However, this narrative may oversimplify matters, as not all players thrive post-United, and individual career paths vary. McTominay’s journey highlights the potential for reinvention elsewhere, but it also underscores United’s challenges in maximizing their roster.

see also: Toto Wolff provides firm update on George Russell future and shares Kimi Antonelli regret

 As fans celebrate McTominay’s triumphs, the debate intensifies over whether United’s system or management is hindering success, with his Serie A glory serving as a poignant reminder of what might have been at Old Trafford.